
MESSAGE FROM OUTSIDE THE ART WORLD
MESSAGE FROM OUTSIDE THE ART WORLD
Here we have the case of an artist who lives in reality and makes artifacts out of the experience.
Mine is only one approach among many photographers making an art of reality, while much of the art world continues to yap from the perspective of comfort.
Are we still saying that photography has no special relationship to reality and truth?
Suppose I develop dementia and finally agree with this bullshit. It would still be true for me — and I could prove it.
What about experience? Does experience have a special relationship to reality?
REALSTILL depends almost entirely on experience. Being there. Returning. Knowing the place, the people, the circumstances. Watching things change, disappear, fall apart, or somehow survive. The photographs are artifacts left behind by that experience. They are not the reason for living it.
Does this have no special relationship to reality? Or does sitting in academia, staring at a screen, or working in a studio, smoking your favorite weed and dancing to your favorite music, have an equal claim?
A photograph is not reality. No shit. How long must we continue announcing the obvious as though it were a revelation?Neither is a sculpture a quarry.Saying photography has no special relationship to reality is like saying sculpture has no special relationship to matter — stone, steel, bronze, glass.You can argue about what the material means once the artist has worked on it. You can argue about its form, its transformation, its interpretation, even its truthfulness. You cannot seriously argue that the material was never there.
Photography is no different in this fundamental respect. Light reflected from something in the world reaches the camera. What the photographer does with that encounter is another matter entirely. A photograph can deceive, distort, exaggerate, invent a meaning, or reveal something that would otherwise remain unseen. None of that erases the encounter.
The reality of the encounter and the truth of its interpretation are two different things. Photography has a particular causal relationship to the world. That does not make every photograph truthful. Confusing those two propositions is where the intellectual sleight of hand begins.
The photograph of the woman outside in the winter city came from the deep end — death and life, falsehood and truth, and whatever mess lies between them.
That’s where I live, too. It’s blood simple, and I can’t help it.
